Home → Cities →

Shelter Island Town, NY Crime Rate

Population: 3,305 • Latest FBI Data

95Score
A
Above Average Safety
1
Violent Crimes
30.3/100k · 6% of total
15
Property Crimes
453.9/100k · 94% of total
0
Murders
0
Robberies
1
Assaults
3
Burglaries

Is Shelter Island Town, NY Safe?

Shelter Island Town, NY is a safe city with a safety score of 95/100, placing it safer than 100% of US cities. The city ranks #25 out of 8,874 US cities in our safety database.

The violent crime rate of 30.3 per 100k is 92% below the national average (380 per 100k). Violent crime accounts for 50% of all reported incidents.

This city is generally suitable for families, retirees, and visitors.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Shelter Island Town, NY safe to live in?
Shelter Island Town, NY is considered a safe city, scoring 95/100. It is safer than 100% of US cities. Crime rates are well below the national average, making it suitable for families, students, and retirees.
What is Shelter Island Town, NY's crime rate?
Shelter Island Town, NY has a violent crime rate of 30.3 per 100,000 residents (below the national average of 380) and a property crime rate of 453.9 per 100k. It ranks #25 out of 8,874 US cities.
Is Shelter Island Town, NY safe at night?
With a safety score of 95/100, Shelter Island Town, NY is generally safe at night. Standard precautions like staying in well-lit areas are recommended, but most residents feel comfortable walking after dark.
Is Shelter Island Town, NY good for families?
Yes, Shelter Island Town, NY is generally suitable for families with its safety score of 95/100.

Crime Summary

⚠️ Biggest Concern
Property Crime
453.9/100k
✅ Safest Aspect
Violent Crime
30.3/100k (92% below US avg)

Shelter Island Town, NY has below-average crime rates across the board — both violent and property crime are below national averages.

Explore More

Nearby: Carroll Town · Fishkill Town · Marlborough Town · Poughkeepsie Town · Canajoharie Village

State: Safest Cities in New York

Rankings: US City Rankings · ZIP Code Lookup · County Data

Compare Shelter Island Town with Other Cities

See how Shelter Island Town ranks against other cities in New York

View New York Rankings →