Carmel, IN vs St. Paul, MN

Carmel is safer with a higher safety score by 28 points. Carmel, IN has a safety score of 88/100 while St. Paul, MN has 60/100, based on FBI Uniform Crime Report data.

Carmel, IN has a violent crime rate of 66.0 per 100,000 residents, while St. Paul, MN has 617.7 per 100,000. Lower rates indicate safer communities. The national average is approximately 380 per 100,000.

Carmel, IN has a property crime rate of 812.7 per 100,000, compared to 2834.1 per 100,000 in St. Paul, MN. Property crimes include burglary, theft, and motor vehicle theft.

Safety scores range from 0-100, combining violent crime rates, property crime rates, and population data from the FBI UCR. Higher scores mean safer cities. Grades: A (80+), B (65-79), C (50-64), D (40-49), F (below 40).

Based on crime data alone, Carmel is safer. However, safety is just one factor — also consider cost of living, job market, schools, and quality of life. Visit our city pages for more details on each.